📞 Sell Your Erie County House Fast → (716) 800-2274 or
×

Tenants & rentals

Squatters’ Rights in New York (2026): How to Evict a Squatter in Buffalo

Do squatters have rights in New York? A 2024 law says a squatter isn't a tenant. How to evict one in Buffalo: police, the 10-day notice and which court.

Get a cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.

Name

Do squatters have rights in New York? Very few. Since April 2024, New York law says plainly that “a tenant shall not include a squatter” (RPAPL §711). Staying 30 days no longer turns a squatter into a tenant. But you still can’t throw them out yourself. If the police won’t remove them, you serve a 10-day notice to quit and go to court (Buffalo City Court inside the city, your town or village court elsewhere). A squatter can only take ownership through adverse possession, which takes at least 10 years and, in most cases, a claim of right: a reasonable basis to believe the property is theirs.

This guide is for owners in Buffalo, Erie County and Niagara County who found someone living in a house they own, often a vacant, inherited or out-of-state house. The legal facts below are current as of October 2026, with the statute cited for each one. This is general information, not legal advice; talk to a New York attorney about your situation.

What counts as a squatter in New York?

The label matters, because it decides which notice you serve and which court path you take. Here are the four people you might find in your house:

  • Squatter: someone who entered without permission from anyone entitled to the property and stays without title, right or permission. That is the exact definition now in RPAPL §711.
  • Licensee: someone who was allowed in, like a relative, a friend, a caretaker or a guest of a former tenant, whose permission ended or was revoked. Covered by RPAPL §713(7).
  • Tenant: someone with a lease, written or oral, who pays or agreed to pay rent. Tenants get the full eviction process.
  • Holdover tenant: a tenant whose lease ended and who won’t leave. The landlord must give 30, 60 or 90 days’ written notice, depending on how long they’ve lived there or the lease term, whichever is longer (RPL §226-c), before a holdover case.

Squatters and licensees both get a 10-day notice to quit. Tenants get longer notices and more protections. If you’re not sure which one you have, that question alone is worth a call to an attorney.

What changed in April 2024?

For years, owners heard that after 30 days a squatter “becomes a tenant.” That idea came from the 30-day language in RPAPL §711. In the FY2025 state budget, signed in April 2024, New York added two sentences to that section: a tenant does not include a squatter, and a squatter is a person who “enters onto or intrudes upon real property without the permission of the person entitled to possession” and keeps occupying it without title, right or permission.

The sponsors said the point was that squatters “are not tenants and therefore not subject to tenant rights or protections after 30 days” (NY Senate press release, April 22, 2024, based on bills S8996/A9772).

What the change did not do: it didn’t create a new fast-track eviction, and it didn’t require police to remove anyone. A person who shows up with a lease, even a fake one, or who says a family member let them in, can still end up in front of a judge.

Will the police remove a squatter in Buffalo?

Sometimes. Knowingly entering or staying unlawfully in a dwelling is criminal trespass in the second degree, a class A misdemeanor (Penal Law §140.15). If someone just broke in and you can show you own the house, officers may treat it as a trespass. If the person claims a lease, rent payments, or permission from anyone, officers often call it a civil matter and send you to court. Each call is a judgment by the officers on scene, so bring your deed and ask for a report number either way.

How to remove a squatter in New York: step by step

  1. Confirm they have no right to be there, and gather proof. Make sure there’s no lease, rental agreement or permission from you, a co-owner, an executor or a property manager. Then pull together your deed or estate papers, recent tax bills, utility accounts in your name, and dated photos of the house before and after. If you inherited the house, have your Letters Testamentary or Letters of Administration ready, since they show who has authority over the estate’s property.
  2. Call the police. Use 911 if a break-in is happening or anyone is in danger; otherwise the non-emergency line. Show proof of ownership and ask them to treat it as trespass. Get the report number either way.
  3. Serve a 10-day notice to quit. If they stay, a removal case under RPAPL §713 starts with a written 10-day notice, served the way RPAPL §735 requires. The ground for a squatter is §713(3). For a licensee it is §713(7).
  4. File the petition. Inside the City of Buffalo, file in Buffalo City Court’s Housing and Landlord/Tenant Court at 50 Delaware Avenue; check the current filing fee with the clerk. Outside the city, the case starts in the local town or village court (RPAPL §701). Ask the clerk where and when it will be heard.
  5. Serve the petition. The notice of petition and petition must be served at least 10 and no more than 17 days before the court date (RPAPL §733). Keep the affidavit of service.
  6. Go to court. If you win, you get a judgment of possession and a warrant.
  7. Let the officer execute the warrant. A marshal, sheriff or constable carries it out after giving at least 14 days’ notice (RPAPL §749). You don’t change the locks until that happens.

Squatter, licensee or tenant: which path and how long?

Situation Legal path Typical speed
Stranger broke in recently, no papers Police report for criminal trespass Can be same day if officers act; if not, go to court
Squatter stays after police call it civil 10-day notice to quit, then §713(3) case in city, town or village court Often weeks if they don’t fight it
Someone you, a relative or a past tenant let in 10-day notice to quit, then §713(7) licensee case Often weeks; can take months if contested
Occupant shows a lease or rent receipts (real or fake) Court decides if they’re a tenant Can take months
Former tenant whose lease ended 30/60/90-day notice under RPL §226-c, then holdover case Can take months

Timing depends on service, the court calendar, adjournments, and whether the occupant hires a lawyer. Nobody can promise you a date.

Do you need a lawyer to evict a squatter?

You aren’t required to have one. But the notice has to be the right one, served the right way, on the right ground, and a mistake in notice or service can get a case dismissed so it has to start over. A landlord-tenant attorney is worth it if the occupant claims a lease, the owner has died, or the case is contested.

If you don’t have an attorney, the Bar Association of Erie County runs a Lawyer Referral and Information Service at (716) 852-3100. Before you start, expect a court filing fee, a process server, the marshal’s or sheriff’s fee to execute the warrant, and attorney’s fees if you hire one. Get the court’s current fee from the clerk and a written quote from any attorney.

What not to do (even when you’re furious)

  • Don’t change the locks while they’re living there.
  • Don’t shut off heat, water or electric to force them out.
  • Don’t remove their belongings or take the doors off.
  • Don’t threaten them or bring friends to “handle it.”
  • Don’t take money from them. Accepting rent can blur the line between squatter and tenant.

New York’s unlawful eviction law, RPAPL §768, makes it a class A misdemeanor to force out an occupant with threats, lockouts or utility shutoffs, with civil penalties of $1,000 to $10,000 per violation, plus up to $100 a day if you don’t restore them. That section protects people who lawfully occupied the unit 30 days or more, or have a lease. A squatter may not qualify, but you won’t know until a judge decides, and anyone put out “in a forcible or unlawful manner” can sue for treble damages under RPAPL §853. The court route is slower. It’s also the one that doesn’t backfire.

Can a squatter take ownership of my house? (Adverse possession in NY)

Almost never. To win title by adverse possession in New York, the occupant needs 10 years of possession (CPLR 212(a)) that was “adverse, under claim of right, open and notorious, continuous, exclusive, and actual” (RPAPL §501(2)).

The big hurdle is claim of right. Since the 2008 amendments (Laws of 2008, ch. 269, for claims filed on or after July 7, 2008), it means “a reasonable basis for the belief that the property belongs to the adverse possessor” (RPAPL §501(3)). Someone who knows they broke into your house has a hard time showing that.

One exception to know: claim of right isn’t required if the owner can’t be found in the county clerk’s records and located by reasonable means. If you inherited the house or live out of state, keep the deed recorded and your mailing address current with the tax office. Also note that small things like a neighbor’s fence or mowing over the line are treated as permissive, not adverse (RPAPL §543).

Protecting a vacant or inherited house in Buffalo

Squatting usually starts the same way: an empty house, nobody checking, and a neighbor who noticed lights at night. A Buffalo winter makes it worse, because an empty house is cold and someone desperate wants in. A few habits help:

  • Visit or send someone weekly. Walk every floor, the basement and the garage. Out of state? Ask a neighbor you trust and give them your number.
  • Make it look lived in. Shovel the walk and steps after snow, cut the grass, collect mail and flyers, and put a couple of lights on timers. An unshoveled walk in January tells everyone the house is empty.
  • Lock the back. Basement windows, side doors and back porches on older Buffalo doubles are the usual way in. Use real locks and screw or board vulnerable openings.
  • Winterize. Keep heat on at a safe level or have the plumbing drained. Frozen pipes and squatters often show up in the same house.
  • Post “No Trespassing” signs and keep your ownership papers in one folder you can grab fast.
  • Tell your insurer it’s vacant. Many policies limit coverage once a house has been vacant or unoccupied for more than 60 consecutive days. That’s the condition in New York’s standard fire policy form (Insurance Law §3404), though your policy’s terms may differ, so check yours. Ask about a vacancy endorsement or a vacant-dwelling policy.
  • If the owner died, the person who brings a removal case is usually the executor or administrator, once Erie County Surrogate’s Court issues Letters. Talk to the estate’s attorney early.

If you live far away, our guide for out-of-state owners selling a Buffalo house covers the rest.

Selling a house with a squatter in it

You don’t have to finish a court case before you sell. A squatter affects who’s living in the house, not who owns it. Your title stays yours, and a buyer who understands occupied houses can take the problem with the property.

That’s what we do. Rust Belt Cash Offer buys houses in Buffalo, Erie County and Niagara County as-is, with the squatter situation unresolved. You don’t need to make repairs or clean out first; take what you want and leave the rest. Depending on the situation, once there’s a signed agreement, we can help with dealing with squatters or evictions through the proper legal process.

  • Offer: a cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.
  • Timing: Close in as little as 5 days when the title is clear and ready. Title problems? If we’re buying the deed without an attorney or title insurance, we can close in as little as 48–72 hours. Most closings take 14–30 days.
  • Costs: we cover all closing costs, and there are no commissions.

A cash sale makes sense when the case could drag on, the house needs work, or you’re tired of carrying taxes and insurance on a house you can’t use. A cash offer is our main option. If that isn’t the right fit, we may have other solutions; tell us your situation.

Own a rental with paying tenants too? See selling a rental property in Buffalo, selling a tenant-occupied rental in Buffalo, and how cash for keys works in New York.

Get your cash offer or call (716) 800-2274.

Squatters’ rights in New York: FAQ

How long before a squatter gets rights in New York?

Under the April 2024 change to RPAPL §711, a squatter does not become a tenant after 30 days, or ever. They still can’t be removed by force; you need the police or a court order. Ownership through adverse possession takes at least 10 years plus a claim of right.

Can police remove squatters in New York?

They can when they treat it as criminal trespass, and the 2024 law makes clear a squatter isn’t a tenant. In practice, if the person shows a lease or claims someone let them in, officers often send the owner to court. Bring your deed and ask for a report number.

Can I change the locks or turn off the utilities on a squatter?

No. Lockouts and utility shutoffs can be unlawful eviction under RPAPL §768, a class A misdemeanor with civil penalties of $1,000 to $10,000 per violation. Wait for the warrant to be executed by a marshal, sheriff or constable.

How long does it take to remove a squatter in Buffalo?

If police act, it can be the same day. If you go to court, an uncontested case often takes weeks, counting the 10-day notice, 10–17 days of petition service, and 14 days’ notice before the warrant is executed. If the occupant fights or claims a lease, it can take months.

How much does it cost to remove a squatter?

There’s a court filing fee for the petition (ask the Buffalo City Court clerk or your town or village court for the current amount), plus process-server costs and any attorney fees, which vary.

Can a squatter take my house in New York?

Only through adverse possession: 10 years of open, continuous, exclusive and actual possession under a claim of right. Since 2008, claim of right means a reasonable basis for believing the property belongs to them, which a known intruder rarely has. Keeping your deed recorded and address current closes the main exception.

Can I sell my house with a squatter living in it?

Yes. A squatter doesn’t change who owns the house, so you can sell it as-is to a buyer willing to take it occupied. Rust Belt Cash Offer buys these houses across Erie and Niagara County. Depending on the situation, once there’s a signed agreement, we can help with dealing with squatters or evictions through the proper legal process.

What if the house belonged to a parent who died?

The executor or administrator usually brings the removal case once the Surrogate’s Court issues Letters Testamentary or Letters of Administration. Until then, call the police about any break-in and talk to the estate attorney about next steps.

How do I report a squatter in Buffalo?

Call 911 if someone is breaking in right now or anyone is in danger. Otherwise call the Buffalo Police non-emergency line at (716) 853-2222 (Buffalo Police) and ask for officers to come out. Have your deed or tax bill ready and write down the report number.

Where do I file to remove a squatter in Cheektowaga, Amherst or another Erie County town?

You start in your local town or village court. Some town cases are heard somewhere else: the Town of Hamburg, for example, says evictions filed in its court are heard in Erie County’s Landlord Tenant HUB Court at Buffalo City Court, and that you file locally, not with the HUB Court. Ask your town or village court clerk where your case will be heard. In Niagara County, ask your local justice court clerk how they handle these cases. For a town-by-town list, see which court hears an eviction in your town or village.

Will my homeowners insurance cover squatter damage to a vacant house?

Possibly not. New York’s standard fire policy suspends coverage while a building has been vacant or unoccupied for more than 60 consecutive days, unless the policy says otherwise (Insurance Law §3404). Call your agent as soon as the house is empty and ask about a vacancy endorsement or a vacant-dwelling policy.

Can I sell an inherited house with a squatter in it before the estate is settled?

You can sign a contract, but the sale can’t close until Erie County Surrogate’s Court issues Letters, because only the executor or administrator named in them can sign the deed (NY Courts: probate; administration). Signing early doesn’t speed up the court. Once Letters issue, a buyer who takes occupied houses can close with the squatter still there.

What notice do I give a squatter in New York?

A written 10-day notice to quit, served the way RPAPL §735 requires, before you file the case (RPAPL §713). The ground is §713(3) for someone who squatted without permission, and §713(7) for a relative or guest whose permission ended or was revoked.

Which court handles squatter cases in Buffalo and Erie County?

Inside the City of Buffalo, Buffalo City Court’s Housing and Landlord/Tenant Court at 50 Delaware Avenue. Outside the city, start in your local town or village court. Ask the clerk where and when your case will be heard.

What is the legal definition of a squatter in New York?

A person who enters onto or intrudes upon real property without the permission of the person entitled to possession, and keeps occupying it without title, right or permission (RPAPL §711, as amended in 2024).

Do I need a lawyer to remove a squatter?

Not always. You aren’t required to have one. If the occupant claims a lease, the owner has died, or the case is contested, talk to a landlord-tenant attorney. The Bar Association of Erie County’s referral service is at (716) 852-3100.

Can I sell instead of going to court?

Yes. A squatter doesn’t change who owns the house. We buy houses in Buffalo and Erie County as-is, and an occupant doesn’t automatically rule a sale out. Depending on the situation, once there’s a signed agreement, we can help with dealing with squatters or evictions through the proper legal process.

Sources

  • RPAPL §711 (tenant does not include a squatter; squatter definition)
  • RPAPL §713 (10-day notice to quit; squatters §713(3), licensees §713(7))
  • RPAPL §733 and §749 (petition service; 14-day warrant notice)
  • RPAPL §768 and §853 (unlawful eviction penalties; treble damages)
  • RPAPL §501 and CPLR 212(a) (adverse possession; 10 years)
  • Buffalo City Court Housing and Landlord/Tenant Court (where to file in the city)
  • NY Senate press release, April 22, 2024 (purpose of the 2024 change)
  • Penal Law §140.15 (criminal trespass, dwelling)
  • RPAPL §735 (service of notice and petition)
  • Insurance Law §3404 (standard fire policy, vacancy)

Legal facts current as of October 2026. This is general information, not legal advice; talk to a New York attorney about your situation.

Get your cash offer

Cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.

Name
Scroll to Top
Rust Belt Cash Offer
Rust Belt Cash Offer
Hey! Got a Buffalo property you're thinking about? Happy to help.
★★★★★
Google 5.0 reviews
Since 2020
Buying WNY houses
350+
Homes bought
BBB A+
Accredited since 6/2/2021
(716) 800-2274 Tap to call
Rust Belt Cash Offer logo

Rust Belt Cash Offer

(716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274

Phone answered 24/7 · Hablamos español

Rust Belt Cash Offer · 50 Fountain Plaza, Suite 1400, Buffalo, NY 14202 · (716) 800-2274 · https://www.rbcashoffer.com/ · info@rbcashoffer.com

Printed from: https://www.rbcashoffer.com/blog/how-to-get-rid-of-squatters-in-buffalo-ny/
Page last updated: October 31, 2026

General information, not legal advice. Rust Belt Cash Offer is a home buyer, not a law firm.