📞 Sell Your Erie County House Fast → (716) 800-2274 or
×

I’m selling a rental with an eviction case already filed. What happens to the case?

Get a cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.

Name

Selling the house doesn’t end the case on its own, and it doesn’t hand the case to the buyer on its own either. New York’s general rule is that after a transfer, a case “may be continued by or against the original parties unless the court directs the person to whom the interest is transferred to be substituted or joined in the action” (CPLR 1018).

The catch is who’s allowed to bring an eviction. A summary proceeding can only be brought by the people listed in RPAPL §721, starting with “the landlord or lessor,” and the petition has to state the petitioner’s interest in the property (RPAPL §741). Once you’ve closed, you’re no longer the landlord. So the usual path is for the buyer to ask the court to be substituted as the petitioner, or to start a new case. Which one works depends on the kind of case, how far along it is, and the judge.

Facts checked as of October 24, 2026. General information, not legal advice. This page covers residential evictions in Erie and Niagara counties.

  • BBB A+ rated, Accredited since 6/2/2021
  • 350+ houses bought and sold

The two rules that decide it

CPLR 1018 lets a case keep going after a transfer. It applies to civil cases generally. It doesn’t force the buyer into the case. It says the case can continue with the original parties unless the court orders the new owner substituted or added. A motion to substitute can be made “by the successors or representatives of a party or by any party” (CPLR 1021). If substitution should happen and doesn’t happen within a reasonable time, the court can dismiss as to that party, and that dismissal isn’t on the merits unless the court says so (CPLR 1021).

RPAPL §721 limits who can bring an eviction. The list includes the landlord or lessor, a buyer at a foreclosure or tax sale who has received a deed, the person entitled to possession when someone squats, and others. A petition has to be verified by a person on that list, or by their attorney or agent, and must state the petitioner’s interest in the property (RPAPL §741(1)).

Put together: a seller who no longer owns the house may not be the right person to win possession for the buyer. How a judge handles a sale in the middle of a case is up to that judge. We didn’t find a statute or an appeals court ruling that settles it for Erie or Niagara County courts, so don’t count on the case simply carrying over. Depending on the court and the facts, the buyer may be substituted, or may need to start a new case.

Non-payment case or holdover case

The kind of case matters, because each one rests on something different.

  • Non-payment case. This rests on rent owed under the lease and a written 14-day rent demand (RPAPL §711(2)). The rent in the demand was owed to you, the seller. Who gets to collect back rent after closing comes down to your purchase contract. If you keep the right to that money, the buyer may have little to pursue in your case, and a new demand from the buyer may make more sense. See what happens to deposits, prepaid rent and back rent at closing.
  • Holdover case. This rests on the tenancy having ended, for example after a lawful non-renewal notice (RPAPL §711(1)). The right to possession is what passes to the buyer with the deed, so a holdover case is often the easier one for a buyer to take over. The court still decides.

Either way, a sale generally doesn’t end the lease. New York gives a buyer of leased property the same remedies under the lease that you had, by entry, action or otherwise, including for unpaid rent (Real Property Law §223). Outside a Good Cause locality, the 30, 60 or 90 day notice rules for non-renewal still apply (Real Property Law §226-c). No Erie or Niagara County locality was on the State’s Good Cause list as of May 4, 2026.

What the buyer needs to continue the case

If the buyer wants to step into your case rather than start over, these are the usual pieces. The court decides whether to allow it.

  1. Proof it now owns the house. The deed, recorded or at least delivered, so the buyer can state its interest the way RPAPL §741(1) requires.
  2. A motion to substitute. Filed in the court that has the case, asking to be substituted or joined under CPLR 1018 and 1021, with notice to the tenant.
  3. Buffalo rental compliance, if the house is in the City. In the City of Buffalo, a missing Certificate of Rental Compliance can bar a non-payment case for the period it was denied or revoked. See what happens without a Certificate of Rental Compliance.
  4. Your case papers. The rent demand or termination notice, the notice of petition and petition, the affidavit of service, and any stipulation or order already entered. If the case has settled into a payment agreement, the buyer needs to know its terms.
  5. The rent ledger and lease. The lease, any renewals, and an accurate ledger showing what was owed before closing and what’s owed after.
  6. Clear paperwork on back rent. Your contract should say who keeps the right to rent owed before closing. A buyer pursuing that rent usually needs it assigned in writing.
  7. An attorney, if the buyer is a company. Under CPLR 321(a), a corporation generally has to appear through an attorney, with limited exceptions such as small claims. Check with the court how it treats an LLC.

If the case already ended in a judgment for you, the warrant is the next step. The court issues it to the officer who carries it out, and the officer must give the tenant at least 14 days’ written notice before executing it (RPAPL §749). In a non-payment case, the court must vacate the warrant if the full rent due is paid or deposited with the court before it’s executed, unless the landlord shows the tenant withheld rent in bad faith (RPAPL §749(3)).

Which court the case is in

A substitution motion goes to the court handling the case. Courts of civil jurisdiction in a city and town or village justice courts can all hear evictions (RPAPL §701).

  • City of Buffalo. Buffalo City Court. Its Housing Part handles the City’s non-payment and holdover cases, which usually start with alternative dispute resolution run by court attorneys.
  • Erie County towns and villages. You file in the local town or village court, but the State court system says non-payment and holdover petitions filed in Erie County’s town and village courts are transferred to the Erie County Landlord-Tenant HUB Court, located in Buffalo Housing Court, and heard remotely. If your case went to the HUB Court, ask the HUB Court clerk where a substitution motion should be filed.
  • Lackawanna and the City of Tonawanda. Each has its own city court.
  • Niagara County. Niagara Falls, Lockport and North Tonawanda have city courts, and the towns have town courts. The Erie County HUB Court doesn’t cover Niagara County, so ask the court clerk.

For a town-by-town table, see which court hears an eviction in your town or village.

Your choices before closing

There’s no single right answer. The choice depends on how far the case has gone and what the buyer wants.

  • Finish the case first. If you’re close to a judgment or a settlement, finishing may be simplest. It can also push back your closing.
  • Sell with the case open. The buyer then decides whether to seek substitution or start fresh. Agree in your contract who controls the case after closing and who keeps any back rent.
  • Settle with the tenant. A written agreement in court, such as a move-out date or a payment plan, can give the buyer a clearer picture than an open case.
  • End the case. If the buyer plans to keep the tenant or file its own case, you may end yours. Ask your landlord-tenant attorney how that affects any money you’re owed.

If the tenant is behind because of money trouble, it’s also worth knowing what help exists before you decide. See programs that may pay back rent so a tenant can stay.

Where we fit

We buy houses as-is in Buffalo and across Erie County and Niagara County. A rental can be sold with the tenants living there, and we can help with the tenant side depending on the situation. A cash offer is our main option, made within 24 hours, usually by phone. We cover all closing costs, and there are no open houses.

We look at a lot of houses, and we can’t buy every one. If a cash sale isn’t a good fit for your rental, we’ll tell you first. Finishing the case and then listing with an agent, or keeping the rental once the tenant situation is settled, may get you more. We may also have other solutions, so tell us your situation.

Close in as little as 5 days when the title is clear and ready. Title problems? If we’re buying the deed without an attorney or title insurance, we can close in as little as 48–72 hours. Most closings take 14–30 days.

Want to talk it through first? Contact us or call (716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274. For the bigger picture, read selling a rental property in Buffalo or selling a tenant-occupied rental under New York’s tenant laws.

Get your cash offer

Cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.

Name

Questions landlords ask

Does selling the house end the eviction case?

Not automatically. Under CPLR 1018 a case can continue with the original parties after a transfer unless the court orders the new owner substituted or added. Whether a seller who no longer owns the house can still get possession is a separate question, because RPAPL §721 limits who can bring an eviction.

Can I keep the case and still collect the back rent after closing?

The right to rent owed before closing is something your purchase contract should spell out. Possession is a different matter, since it belongs to the new owner after closing. Talk with your landlord-tenant attorney about whether to pursue the rent in this case or separately.

The tenant has a court date next week and we close next month. What should I do?

Go to the court date. Missing it can lead to the case being dismissed. Tell the buyer about the date and what happens there, since it affects what the buyer is getting.

Is a judgment I already won good for the buyer?

A judgment and warrant name the petitioner. If the warrant hasn’t been carried out by closing, the buyer will usually need the court’s permission to be substituted before it can rely on them. Ask the court clerk how that court handles it.

Does the tenant get any say in substitution?

A substitution motion is made on notice, so the tenant can respond. Ask your landlord-tenant attorney which defenses the tenant can still raise against a new owner.

Is any of this different in Niagara County?

The statutes are statewide, so CPLR 1018 and RPAPL §721 apply the same way. The courts are different: the Erie County HUB Court is for Erie County town and village cases only.

Sources

  • CPLR 1018, substitution upon transfer of interest; CPLR 1021, substitution procedure and dismissal for failure to substitute (nysenate.gov, revision of 2014-09-22; read October 24, 2026)
  • CPLR 321(a), appearance in person or by attorney (nysenate.gov, revision of 2022-12-23; read October 24, 2026)
  • RPAPL §701, courts that hear summary proceedings (revision of 2014-09-22); §711(1) and (2), grounds and the 14-day rent demand (revision of 2024-12-13); §721, person who may maintain the proceeding (revision of 2014-09-22); §741, contents of petition (revision of 2026-01-02); §749, warrant, 14-day notice and vacating on payment (revision of 2019-06-28) (nysenate.gov; read October 24, 2026)
  • New York Real Property Law §223, rights where property or lease is transferred (nysenate.gov, revision of 2014-09-22; read October 24, 2026); Real Property Law §226-c (nysenate.gov)
  • NYS Unified Court System, Buffalo City Court, Housing & Landlord / Tenant Court page: Landlord and Tenant proceedings, alternative dispute resolution, and the Erie County Housing Court (HUB Court) (nycourts.gov; read October 24, 2026)
  • NYS Homes and Community Renewal, Good Cause Eviction localities notice “as of May 4, 2026” (no Erie or Niagara County locality)

General information about New York eviction procedure as of October 24, 2026, not legal advice. Rust Belt Cash Offer is a home buyer, not a law firm. Rust Belt Cash Offer · 50 Fountain Plaza, Suite 1400, Buffalo, NY 14202 · (716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274

Scroll to Top
Rust Belt Cash Offer
Rust Belt Cash Offer
Hey! Got a Buffalo property you're thinking about? Happy to help.
★★★★★
Google 5.0 reviews
Since 2020
Buying WNY houses
350+
Homes bought
BBB A+
Accredited since 6/2/2021
(716) 800-2274 Tap to call
Rust Belt Cash Offer logo

Rust Belt Cash Offer

(716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274

Phone answered 24/7 · Hablamos español

Rust Belt Cash Offer · 50 Fountain Plaza, Suite 1400, Buffalo, NY 14202 · (716) 800-2274 · https://www.rbcashoffer.com/ · info@rbcashoffer.com

Printed from: https://www.rbcashoffer.com/blog/sell-rental-pending-eviction-case-new-york/
Page last updated: October 31, 2026

General information, not legal advice. Rust Belt Cash Offer is a home buyer, not a law firm.