Tenants & rentals
Cash-for-Keys in New York After HSTPA: What Landlords Can Offer
Cash-for-keys in New York after HSTPA: when it is legal, what a written deal needs, how to size an offer, and why selling occupied can skip it entirely.
Get a cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.
Cash-for-keys is legal in New York when the tenant agrees to it freely and gets real money in exchange for moving out by a set date, and the deal should be in writing. There is no set amount: landlords usually size the offer against what a contested holdover case would cost in time, legal fees and lost rent, and often pay after the tenant has moved out and returned the keys. What you can’t do is pair the offer with pressure, lockouts or utility shutoffs (RPAPL §768). Here’s what a proper agreement needs, and when it’s simpler to sell with the tenant in place.
Why cash-for-keys exists now
The 2019 Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act (HSTPA) made New York evictions slower and stricter: you must give 30, 60 or 90 days’ written notice (depending on how long the tenant has lived there) before you decline to renew a lease, a non-payment case starts with a 14-day rent demand, and every removal goes through court. In the City of Buffalo you can still decline to renew without a specific reason after proper notice, because Buffalo has not opted into the state’s 2024 Good Cause Eviction law (some nearby towns are debating it). But if the tenant doesn’t leave, a holdover case in Buffalo City Court can take months, with real legal cost and no guaranteed result. Against that backdrop, paying a tenant a fair sum to leave on a set date is often faster, cheaper, and far less adversarial than litigating. It’s a voluntary agreement: the tenant chooses to take the deal.
Is cash-for-keys legal in New York?
Yes, when it’s truly voluntary and properly documented. What makes it lawful (and enforceable) is that the tenant agrees freely, in writing, in exchange for real consideration. What makes it illegal is using it as a threat or pairing it with pressure tactics. You cannot:
- Coerce or harass the tenant into “agreeing”
- Shut off utilities, change the locks, or remove belongings to force a move (these are illegal lockouts with serious penalties)
- Misrepresent the tenant’s rights to push them out
Done right, it’s a negotiation. Done wrong, it’s tenant harassment.
What a proper New York cash-for-keys agreement includes
Put it in writing. A handshake invites disputes. A solid agreement generally covers:
- The move-out date and the condition the unit must be left in (“broom-clean,” keys returned)
- The payment amount and timing: commonly paid after the tenant has fully vacated and returned keys (or split, with the balance on surrender)
- A clear statement that the move is voluntary
- Mutual release of claims and confirmation the tenancy ends on the date
- Handling of the security deposit (often folded into the deal)
- Both signatures and date
Because this intersects with HSTPA notice rules and any local Good Cause law (check whether your town has opted in), have a New York attorney review your template. And make sure your rental is in good standing first (registration/inspections; see the Buffalo rental registry landlord guide).
How much do landlords typically offer?
There’s no fixed figure. It’s a negotiation that weighs what an eviction would otherwise cost you in time, legal fees, and lost rent. When you frame it that way, a reasonable buyout often pencils out as the cheaper path versus months of litigation. Offer enough to make moving genuinely worthwhile for the tenant, and get the deal in writing.
The simpler alternative: don’t empty it at all
Here’s the move many landlords miss: if your end goal is to sell the property, you may not need the tenant gone at all. Investor buyers routinely purchase tenant-occupied rentals subject to the existing leases and become the new landlord, which means no cash-for-keys, no eviction, no vacancy. See how to sell a tenant-occupied rental in Buffalo and, for inherited rentals, inherited a house with tenants in New York. Cash-for-keys makes sense when you specifically need a vacant unit; if you just want out, selling occupied is usually faster and cheaper. If an eviction case is already filed, see selling a rental with an eviction case already filed.
How Rust Belt Cash Offer helps
If your goal is to exit the rental, we buy tenant-occupied Buffalo and Erie County properties as-is for cash, and we can help with the tenant side depending on the situation. We look at many properties every week and can’t make a cash offer on every one. If yours isn’t a fit, we’ll be the first to say so. When it is, you get a cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.
Call (716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274, email info@rbcashoffer.com, or use the form on this page.
This is general information about New York landlord-tenant law, not legal advice. Have a New York attorney review any cash-for-keys agreement before you use it.
Frequently asked questions
Is cash-for-keys legal in New York after HSTPA?
Yes, when it’s genuinely voluntary and documented in writing with real consideration. It becomes illegal if paired with coercion, harassment, or self-help tactics like lockouts or utility shutoffs.
What should a cash-for-keys agreement include?
A move-out date, required condition, payment amount and timing (often paid after the tenant vacates and returns keys), a statement that it’s voluntary, security-deposit handling, a mutual release, and both signatures. Have an attorney review it.
How much should I offer a tenant to leave?
There’s no set amount. Base it on what a contested eviction would cost you in time, legal fees, and lost rent. A reasonable buyout is often cheaper than a contested case that can take months.
Do I even need the tenant to leave if I’m selling?
Often no. Investor buyers purchase occupied rentals subject to the leases, so you can sell without a cash-for-keys deal or an eviction at all.
What if my tenant turns down a cash-for-keys offer?
Then the tenancy goes on and you follow the normal legal path. When the lease ends you can decline to renew after giving written notice of 30, 60 or 90 days, depending on how long the tenant has lived there (RPL §226-c), and if they stay you would bring a holdover case in Buffalo City Court. You can improve the offer or ask again later, but you can’t pressure, lock out or cut services to a tenant who says no (RPAPL §768).
What if the tenant takes the money and doesn’t move out?
You still can’t change the locks or remove their belongings yourself; only a marshal, sheriff or constable carrying out a court warrant can do that (RPAPL §749). That is why most agreements pay the bulk of the money only after the tenant has moved out and returned the keys. If they stay past the agreed date, you would need a holdover case, and an attorney can tell you how to use the signed agreement in it.
When do I have to return the security deposit after a cash-for-keys move-out?
Within 14 days after the tenant moves out. New York requires you to return the deposit, or give an itemized written statement of any deductions plus the balance, inside that window, and a landlord who misses it loses the right to keep any part of it (GOL §7-108). Spell out in the agreement how the deposit will be handled so there is no dispute later.
Does cash-for-keys come up in a New York foreclosure?
Yes. After a foreclosure sale, the new owner, often the lender, may offer the occupants money to leave instead of going to court. A former owner can only be removed through a court case after a 10-day notice once the deed from the sale has been shown to them (RPAPL §713), and tenants in a foreclosed home generally get at least 90 days or the rest of their lease (RPAPL §1305).
Sources
- Real Property Law §226-c, notice before non-renewal (checked 2026-10-19)
- RPAPL §711, §713, §749, §768 and §1305 (checked 2026-10-19)
- General Obligations Law §7-108, return of security deposits (checked 2026-10-19)
- NYS Homes and Community Renewal, Good Cause Eviction locality notice of May 4, 2026 (checked 2026-10-19)
Get your cash offer
Cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.


