Inherited house & probate
Inherited a House With Tenants in New York? Here’s How to Proceed
Inherited a Buffalo house with tenants? NY notice rules, where an eviction case goes, the city rental registry, and selling with the tenants in place.
Get a cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.
Inheriting a house is one thing. Inheriting one with tenants living in it is another: suddenly you’re not just an heir, you’re a landlord, with New York’s tenant rules to follow. Before you assume you can ask the tenants to leave and sell an empty house, here’s what New York law allows, what to check with the City of Buffalo first, where an eviction case would go, and why selling the property with the tenants in place is often the simplest move.
General information, not legal advice. Facts checked as of October 2026.
First: you inherit the leases and the obligations
When you inherit a tenant-occupied property in New York, you take it subject to the existing leases. You can’t void a valid lease just because ownership changed hands. Whatever terms the prior owner agreed to, you step into, including the security deposit and any promises about repairs or services.
And if the estate isn’t settled yet, the property usually can’t be sold until Surrogate’s Court issues Letters appointing an Executor or Administrator. Once appointed, that fiduciary has the power to take possession of the property, collect the rents and manage it, unless the will or a court order limits that power or the will leaves the house to a specific person (EPTL 11-1.1). Until someone is appointed, ask the estate attorney before any heir collects rent, and keep a record of every payment that comes in. See how long probate takes in New York for the timing.
What to gather before you do anything
Get organized before you make a single decision. You’ll want:
- The lease(s): written, or for a month-to-month tenant, the verbal terms and rent amount.
- A rent ledger or payment history: who’s current, who’s behind, and by how much.
- The security deposit: how much, and where it’s held. In New York the deposit stays the tenant’s money; as the new owner you become responsible for it, and the law requires that tenants be notified of the new account or owner holding it.
- Rental registration and compliance status: Buffalo requires rental registration and inspections. If the prior owner let that lapse, it’s now your problem. How to look it up is just below.
- Any open repairs, complaints, or code violations on the property.
Check the Buffalo rental registry before you decide anything
As of October 2026, the City of Buffalo’s Rental Registration Program, run by the Department of Permit & Inspection Services, registers every non-owner-occupied single and two-family house, plus some three-family and mixed-use buildings, whether or not the units are occupied. The city publishes the registry on OpenData Buffalo, and you can filter it by address to see:
- whether the house is registered, and when the registration expires;
- whether registration fees are owed (the “Milestone” column shows “FEES DUE” or a delinquency notice);
- the result of the city’s rental inspection. A pass means the house was in compliance at that inspection and would receive a Certificate of Rental Compliance.
If the person who died lived in one unit of a double and rented the other, the house may not be owner-occupied anymore, so ask the Rental Registration Office whether it now has to be registered. Look up open violations for the same address in the city’s Code Violations data too. A building with 2 or more units, built before 1980, in one of the county’s listed ZIP codes also falls under New York State’s Lead Rental Registry; the local contact is the Erie County Department of Health. Our guides to the Buffalo rental registry and to failed C of O and rental compliance inspections in Buffalo cover what each of these means for a sale.
You can’t just evict: what New York requires
New York’s 2019 Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act (HSTPA) applies statewide. You inherit the property subject to the existing lease, so the tenant can stay until it ends. If you don’t plan to renew the lease, or you plan to raise the rent 5% or more, you must give the tenant written notice first (Real Property Law §226-c), and any removal goes through court. New York’s separate 2024 Good Cause Eviction law adds limits on non-renewal only in New York City and in cities, towns and villages that opt in. The state’s list dated May 4, 2026 includes no Erie or Niagara County locality; Buffalo has not opted in (NYS Homes and Community Renewal). Check your own town before you act.
The notice period depends on how long the tenant has lived there or the lease term, whichever is longer:
| Tenant has lived there (or lease term) | Minimum written notice |
|---|---|
| Less than 1 year | 30 days |
| 1 to 2 years | 60 days |
| 2 or more years | 90 days |
Those are the notice periods before you decline to renew a lease or raise the rent 5% or more. Where a town has opted into Good Cause, it also limits the reasons you can act on. Other steps have their own clocks: before a non-payment case, the landlord must serve a written rent demand giving at least 14 days’ notice (RPAPL §711(2)), and after the court rules, the marshal or sheriff must give at least 14 days’ written notice before carrying out the eviction warrant (RPAPL §749). An uncontested case can finish in weeks. A contested one commonly takes several months, with real legal cost and no guaranteed outcome.
If a tenant does have to leave: where the case goes
As of October 2026, residential eviction cases for a house inside the City of Buffalo are summary proceedings in Buffalo City Court’s Housing and Landlord/Tenant Court, not Erie County Supreme Court. For a house in the City of Lackawanna or the City of Tonawanda, the case goes to that city’s court; in an Erie County town or village, it is filed in that town or village justice court. Some town cases are heard somewhere else: the Town of Hamburg, for example, says evictions filed in its court are heard in Erie County’s Landlord Tenant HUB Court at Buffalo City Court, and that you file locally, not with the HUB Court. Ask your town or village court clerk where your case will be heard. Who should bring the case for an estate, and when, is a question for the estate attorney, and no one should change the locks, shut off utilities or remove belongings to force a tenant out. For a town-by-town list, see which court hears an eviction in your town or village.
The shortcut: sell it tenant-occupied
Here’s what many heirs don’t realize: you don’t have to remove the tenants to sell. Tenant-occupied properties are bought and sold all the time. An investor buyer takes the property subject to the existing leases and becomes the new landlord. That means you can:
- Skip the eviction process entirely: no court case that can take months, and no legal bills for one.
- Avoid becoming a landlord you never signed up to be, with no rent collection, repairs, or compliance headaches.
- Sell as-is without turning over a unit or making it “show ready.”
- Close once the estate can legally convey title.
Don’t overlook the tax angle
Inherited property generally gets a stepped-up cost basis: the value is reset to fair market value as of the date of death, which can sharply reduce capital-gains tax if you sell. For an inherited rental there can be other tax questions, so it’s worth a quick conversation with your accountant. Our plain-English overview is here: stepped-up basis for inherited property in New York. (General information, not tax advice.)
If you inherited it with siblings
Tenant-occupied inheritances are often shared among several heirs, and not everyone wants the same thing. One wants to keep the rental income, another wants to cash out. A clean sale frequently resolves that standoff. If that’s your situation, see what to do when siblings disagree about an inherited house.
How Rust Belt Cash Offer helps
We buy tenant-occupied inherited homes across Buffalo and Erie County, as-is, with no repairs and no commissions, and we can help with the tenant side depending on the situation. When the house is in an estate, we can sign a purchase agreement early with the executor (or the family member applying to be administrator), with the heirs on board, so we’re ready to close as soon as Letters are issued.
We look at many properties every week and can’t make a cash offer on every one. If yours isn’t a fit, we’ll be the first to say so. When it is, you get a cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone. Call (716) 800-2274, email info@rbcashoffer.com, or use the form on this page.
General information about New York tenancy and inheritance law as of October 2026, not legal advice. Rust Belt Cash Offer is a home buyer, not a law firm.
Frequently asked questions
Can I evict the tenants from a house I inherited in New York?
Not during the lease: you inherit it as-is. When it ends, you can decline to renew after giving the HSTPA notice (30, 60 or 90 days), unless your town has opted into Good Cause (the City of Buffalo has not). If the tenant stays, you need a court case, which commonly takes several months. You cannot remove anyone simply because you’re the new owner.
Do I have to honor the existing lease?
Yes. You inherit the property subject to the existing leases and step into the prior owner’s obligations, including the security deposit.
Does an inherited Buffalo rental have to be registered with the city?
If it’s a non-owner-occupied single or two-family house (and some three-family and mixed-use buildings), yes. As of October 2026, you can check the house’s registration, expiration date, any fees due and its last rental inspection result in the city’s Rental Registry data on OpenData Buffalo, then confirm with the Department of Permit & Inspection Services.
Who collects the rent while the estate is still in probate?
Once Letters are issued, the Executor or Administrator has the power to take possession of the property, collect the rents and manage it, unless the will or a court order says otherwise or the will leaves the house to a specific person (EPTL 11-1.1). Until someone is appointed, ask the estate attorney before any heir collects rent, and keep a record of every payment.
Yes. Investor buyers regularly purchase tenant-occupied properties subject to the leases, which lets you sell without evicting anyone or becoming a long-term landlord.
A relative was living in the house rent-free. How do we get them to leave? Once Letters are issued, the executor or administrator can serve a 10-day notice to quit and, if needed, bring a court case to remove someone who lived there with permission but without a lease (RPAPL §713(7)). In the City of Buffalo, these cases go to Buffalo City Court (NY Courts). Talk with the estate attorney before you serve anything, because family situations can raise extra defenses.
Someone moved in after the owner died without anyone’s permission. Are they a tenant? No. New York law says a squatter, someone who entered without the owner’s permission and stays without any right to be there, is not a tenant (RPAPL §711). Removing them still has to go through the proper legal process, so have the estate attorney handle it.
Do I have to make repairs while the estate is still open? Yes. Whoever is the landlord, including an estate, must keep the units fit to live in and free of conditions that are dangerous to tenants’ health or safety, and tenants can’t waive that right (RPL §235-b). Keep heat, water and urgent repairs going until the house is sold.
What happens to the tenants’ security deposits when the estate sells? They go to the buyer. Within five days after the deed is delivered, the deposits must be turned over to the new owner and each tenant notified by registered or certified mail with the new owner’s name and address (GOL §7-105). That releases the estate from having to repay them.
Get your cash offer
Cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.


