📞 Sell Your Erie County House Fast → (716) 800-2274 or
×

My Buffalo house is in the City’s In Rem 56 tax foreclosure. Can I still sell, and what if I missed a date?

Get a cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.

Name

Possibly, yes, but the window is narrow. The City of Buffalo’s last day to redeem in In Rem 56 was August 28, 2026. The City says that after that date and before the sale planned for 2027, it may still accept payment, but only if everything owed to the City is paid, including newer years. A sale can work in this window only if the City agrees to take that full payoff and it is paid at or before closing.

Do this first: call the City of Buffalo Department of Assessment & Taxation at (716) 851-5733 ext. 2, ask whether your property can still be paid off, and get a written payoff. If the house also owes Erie County taxes, call the County too. They are two separate cases.

Facts checked as of October 19, 2026. General information, not legal advice.

  • BBB A+ rated, Accredited since 6/2/2021
  • 350+ houses bought and sold

What In Rem 56 is, and what it isn’t

In Rem 56 is the City of Buffalo’s current tax foreclosure case. The City forecloses unpaid City taxes, sewer rent and user fees under Article 11 of the New York Real Property Tax Law. This case covers charges from 2023 and earlier that went unpaid for at least 18 months (City of Buffalo In Rem Information and FAQ).

“In rem” means the case is against the property itself, not against you personally. Nobody sold your tax lien to an investor. The City holds its own lien and enforces it in court.

To redeem by August 28, 2026, an owner had to pay all 2023 and prior City taxes, sewer rent and user fees, plus penalties, interest and a $500 foreclosure fee. The City’s FAQ says that if a property is not redeemed by that date, the owner’s interest will be extinguished and the property will be offered at public auction. The City lists that auction as tentative, and dates reported for it have differed, so this page just calls it the sale planned for 2027.

It is not the County’s case. Erie County runs its own tax foreclosure for County taxes under the Erie County Tax Act. Its current case is In Rem 174, and it includes houses inside the City of Buffalo. One house can be in the City’s case, the County’s case, or both. Paying one office does not pay the other. Our Erie County tax foreclosure timeline walks through both cases side by side.

What you can still do after August 28, 2026

Missing the redemption date is serious, but on the City side it is not always the end. Here is what the City and state law say, as of October 2026.

  • Full payment may still be accepted. The City says it may accept payment after the redemption deadline and before the sale, but only if you pay everything owed to the City, including years after 2023. Paying only the 2023 and older amounts is not enough at this stage (City In Rem FAQ).
  • A payment plan alone won’t stop it. The City’s FAQ says repayment plans were available in person, that signing a plan alone does not stop the foreclosure, and that every plan had to be paid off by August 28, 2026. Ask the City directly whether any plan is still possible for your property, and don’t count on one.
  • After judgment, it’s the City’s call. State law lets a tax district, at its discretion, convey a foreclosed parcel back to the former owner who pays the taxes, penalties, interest and other charges, if that happens before the parcel is conveyed to someone else (Real Property Tax Law §1136(4)(a)). That is a choice the City makes, not a right you can demand.

The City also says exemptions are not applied to arrears, so a new exemption won’t shrink what you owe in the case (City In Rem FAQ).

The City takes cash, certified check, money order, or a bank check (the City calls it a bank draft). Personal checks aren’t accepted. Get every payoff in writing, good through a specific date, because interest keeps adding up.

Selling the house in this window

A sale is possible only while the house is still yours to sell and the City will accept a full payoff. Once a judgment gives the City title, you can’t sell it unless the City first agrees to convey it back to you. In practice, three things have to line up:

  1. The City confirms it will accept payment for your property, and you get a written payoff that covers every year owed to the City.
  2. The payoff gets paid at or before closing. The City’s charges come out of the money from the sale, the same way a mortgage payoff does.
  3. The closing happens before the sale planned for 2027, and before the City conveys the property to anyone else. Expect the buyer’s title company to want written proof from the City that the property is out of the case.

If the house is also in the County’s In Rem 174 case, the County’s taxes have to be dealt with too. A sale only helps if both offices are paid.

If the house you live in is in foreclosure, or your mortgage payment is more than 60 days past due, New York’s Home Equity Theft Prevention Act generally gives you 14 business days after signing to cancel a sale contract (Real Property Law §265-a). Whether a tax foreclosure counts under that law isn’t spelled out, so a careful buyer builds that window into the closing date anyway.

If you missed a date

You missed the City’s settlement conference

For In Rem 56, the City said its attorneys would hold settlement conferences on dates it advertised. To take part, you had to be the owner or someone legally authorized to act for the owner, and you could be asked to bring photo ID and papers such as Letters of Administration, Letters Testamentary or a power of attorney (City In Rem FAQ).

The City’s FAQ doesn’t say what happens if you miss one. Don’t assume it’s over. Call the City at (716) 851-5733 ext. 2, explain that you missed the conference, and ask what is still possible for your property.

You missed the deadline to answer in court

An owner who doesn’t redeem or answer can be barred, and the court can enter a judgment by default. In a Real Property Tax Law Article 11 case like the City’s, a motion to reopen a default judgment can’t be brought later than one month after the judgment is entered (RPTL §1131). After a tax deed is recorded, the law presumes the case was handled properly, and after two years that presumption becomes conclusive (RPTL §1137).

Those are short, strict deadlines. If you believe you were never properly notified, or you have a defense, talk with a New York attorney about your case right away. Free help is listed below.

You missed the County’s July 27, 2026 answer date

That date belongs to Erie County’s In Rem 174 case, not the City’s. The County’s last day to redeem was July 6, 2026, its answer deadline was July 27, 2026, and its judgment was filed in August 2026. The County’s homeowner notice warns that after the redemption date, an owner “may be barred from entering into a payment plan or from being permitted to make any payment to save your home.”

Call Erie County Real Property Tax Services at (716) 858-8333 and the County’s In Rem 174 foreclosure hotline at (716) 884-3135, and ask whether anything can still be paid. The County expects its In Rem 174 auction in 2027.

If the County’s case has your house too

Erie County bills County taxes directly to Buffalo homeowners, separate from the City’s bill. If those went unpaid, the house may be on the County’s In Rem 174 list as well. Look up County taxes at paytax.erie.gov or call (716) 858-8333. Then ask the City for its own payoff. Paying the City does not pay the County, and paying the County does not pay the City.

Houses in Lackawanna and the City of Tonawanda are different again: the County tells owners there to contact that city’s own tax office. If you own in Niagara Falls, the City of Niagara Falls enforces its own taxes, so call its Billing and Collections office.

If the house is sold at the 2027 auction

You don’t automatically lose all the value. In Tyler v. Hennepin County (May 25, 2023), the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that a government can’t keep sale money beyond what it is owed. New York then added a surplus process to the Real Property Tax Law in 2024, sections 1195 to 1197.

  • The City works out the surplus. Within 45 days after the sale, the enforcing officer has to determine whether there is a surplus. The officer then reports the sale to the court and, within 10 days of that report, notifies the former owner (RPTL §1196).
  • You have to claim it. For In Rem 56, the City says a former owner, lienholder or judgment creditor files a Notice of Claim with the Erie County Clerk and starts a court proceeding. A referee or judge decides who gets what (City In Rem FAQ).
  • Others can claim ahead of you. Anyone who had a lien or interest in the property right before the judgment can file a claim, including your mortgage lender and judgment creditors (RPTL §1197(1)).
  • The auction price is treated as full value. If the house sold at public auction, you can’t claim the difference between the auction price and what you think the house was worth (RPTL §1197(2)).
  • There is time, but don’t wait. For a residential property where no former homeowner has claimed, the proceeding stays open for at least three years. Surplus nobody claims goes to the tax district (RPTL §1197(4) and (5)).

A surplus claim is a court process with no guaranteed amount. A sale you arrange yourself, before the auction, is a price you agree to. That difference is the main reason to act before the sale planned for 2027 if the City will still take payment.

Your honest options

Options after the In Rem 56 deadline
OptionCan make sense whenThe tradeoff
Pay the City in full and keep the houseYou, or family, can cover everything owed to the City, and the City confirms it will accept it.It takes the full amount, newer years included, before the sale. It is the best outcome if you want to stay.
List with an agentThe house is in good shape, the City confirms it will accept a payoff, and there is enough time before the sale.Listing, a buyer’s mortgage and a closing take time, and the 2027 sale won’t wait. A financed buyer may also be wary of a house in a foreclosure case.
Sell as-is for cashTime is short, the house needs work, or you can’t carry it while it sits on the market.The price reflects the condition and the speed. The City’s payoff still has to be paid at closing.
Do nothing and claim surplus laterNo one can pay and no sale can close in time.A court claim, lienholders can come first, and the auction price counts as full value.

Honest take: if you can pay the City and want to keep the house, do that. If the house is in good condition and the dates allow it, listing will likely bring a higher price. A cash sale fits when the deadline is close, the house needs work, or the house is part of an estate nobody can manage.

Where we fit

We buy houses that are behind on City or County taxes in Buffalo, including Black Rock and Lovejoy, and across Erie County, in towns like Cheektowaga and Tonawanda. A cash offer is our main option, made within 24 hours, usually by phone. We buy as-is, you can take what you want and leave the rest, we cover all closing costs, and there are no open houses.

We look at a lot of houses, and we can’t buy every one. If a cash sale isn’t a good fit for yours, or the City won’t accept a payoff in time, we’ll tell you first. We can only buy from you while the house is still yours. If the City has already taken title by judgment, there’s nothing for us to buy unless the City conveys it back to you. We may also have other solutions, so tell us your situation.

Close in as little as 5 days when the title is clear and ready. Most closings take 14–30 days. Whether a sale can close before the City’s sale depends on the City confirming the payoff, so tell us your dates on the first call.

Want to talk it through first? Contact us or call (716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274. For the bigger picture, read our guide to selling a house with back taxes in Buffalo or see how we buy houses in Buffalo.

Get your cash offer

Cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.

Name

Questions owners ask

Is it too late to pay the City now that August 28 has passed?

Not always. The City says it may accept payment after the redemption deadline and before the sale, if everything owed to the City is paid, including newer years. Call (716) 851-5733 ext. 2 and ask about your property specifically.

Can I stay in the house until the auction?

For its own case, Erie County’s homeowner notice says you have the right to stay in your home until a court orders you to leave. Ask the City how that works in In Rem 56. Either way, staying doesn’t stop the case, and once the property is conveyed after judgment, your ownership ends.

My mother died and her house is in In Rem 56. Who can deal with it?

Only an executor or administrator appointed by the Erie County Surrogate’s Court can sign for the estate, and the house can’t be sold until Letters issue. The City asks for Letters at its settlement conferences. An uncontested case often gets Letters in about 6–12 weeks, which may not fit the City’s timeline, so call the City the same week you start the estate. Our guide to selling a probate house in Buffalo covers the estate side.

Can I buy my house back at the auction?

Don’t plan on it. Erie County’s terms of sale refuse to transfer title to a delinquent owner who buys back their own property at a County auction. For the City’s sale, ask the City at (716) 851-5733 ext. 2.

Someone called offering to “stop” my tax foreclosure for a fee. Is that real?

Be careful. Both the City and the County warn about scams and point owners to free help. Never pay anyone to “save” your house before you’ve called the City yourself. Our guide to foreclosure scams in Buffalo lists the warning signs.

Free help

  • Western New York Law Center: (716) 855-0203 ext. 124
  • Legal Aid: (716) 853-9555
  • Center for Elder Law and Justice: (844) 481-0973
  • NY Attorney General’s Homeowner Protection Program: 1-855-466-3456
  • Bar Association of Erie County Lawyer Referral Service: (716) 852-3100

Sources

  • City of Buffalo, In Rem Information and FAQ, In Rem 56 (buffalony.gov, Document Center; full read October 12, 2026, rechecked through the search index October 19, 2026): August 28, 2026 redemption deadline, $500 fee, 18-month rule, payment after the deadline, payment plans, settlement conferences, surplus claims, payment methods, exemptions
  • City of Buffalo, In Rem Foreclosure page (buffalony.gov): payment-plan line (716) 851-5733 ext. 2, scam warning
  • Erie County Real Property Tax Services, In Rem 174 Frequently Asked Questions (May 2026, erie.gov): July 6 and July 27, 2026 dates, 2027 auction, City of Buffalo, Lackawanna and Tonawanda referrals, free-help numbers
  • Erie County, RPTL §1144 Homeowner Warning Notice, In Rem 174 (May 2026, erie.gov); Erie County filed Judgment, In Rem 174 (August 2026); Erie County 2026 Terms of Sale (erie.gov)
  • New York Real Property Tax Law §§1131, 1136 and 1137 (nysenate.gov, revisions 2014-09-22 and 2024-04-26; checked October 19, 2026)
  • New York Real Property Tax Law §§1195, 1196 and 1197, Title 6, Distribution of Surplus (nysenate.gov, revision 2024-04-26; checked October 19, 2026)
  • Tyler v. Hennepin County, 598 U.S. 631 (2023), decided May 25, 2023 (supremecourt.gov)
  • Real Property Law §265-a, Home Equity Theft Prevention Act, subdivision 5(a) (nysenate.gov, revision 2023-12-15; checked October 19, 2026)

General information about New York and City of Buffalo tax foreclosure as of October 19, 2026, not legal or tax advice. Rust Belt Cash Offer is a home buyer, not a law firm. Rust Belt Cash Offer · 50 Fountain Plaza, Suite 1400, Buffalo, NY 14202 · (716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274

Scroll to Top
Rust Belt Cash Offer
Rust Belt Cash Offer
Hey! Got a Buffalo property you're thinking about? Happy to help.
★★★★★
Google 5.0 reviews
Since 2020
Buying WNY houses
350+
Homes bought
BBB A+
Accredited since 6/2/2021
(716) 800-2274 Tap to call
Rust Belt Cash Offer logo

Rust Belt Cash Offer

(716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274

Phone answered 24/7 · Hablamos español

Rust Belt Cash Offer · 50 Fountain Plaza, Suite 1400, Buffalo, NY 14202 · (716) 800-2274 · https://www.rbcashoffer.com/ · info@rbcashoffer.com

Printed from: https://www.rbcashoffer.com/blog/sell-house-buffalo-in-rem-56/
Page last updated: October 31, 2026

General information, not legal advice. Rust Belt Cash Offer is a home buyer, not a law firm.