📞 Sell Your Erie County House Fast → (716) 800-2274 or
×

Can one owner force the sale of a house in New York?

Get a cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.

Name

Usually, yes. If you own a house with someone as tenants in common or joint tenants, New York law lets you file a partition case asking the court to divide the property or, when it can’t be split without great harm to the owners, to order it sold and the money divided. You don’t need the other owner’s permission to file (Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law §901).

Three big exceptions: a married couple who own the house together, a house still in a deceased owner’s name, and an inherited house that counts as “heirs property,” where extra protections apply. Each is covered below.

A partition case is a lawsuit, and each owner can have a lawyer. It takes time and money, so the cheapest path is often for the owners to agree to sell together.

Facts checked as of October 2026. General information, not legal advice.

  • BBB A+ rated, Accredited since 6/2/2021
  • 350+ houses bought and sold

Who can force a sale, and who can’t

It comes down to how the deed says you own the house. The current deed is on file with the county clerk (the Erie County Clerk or the Niagara County Clerk), so check it first.

How you own the house decides whether you can force a sale
How the deed holds titleCan one owner force a sale?The route
Tenants in common (the default for two or more owners who aren’t married to each other)YesA partition case under RPAPL Article 9
Joint tenants (the deed has to say “joint tenancy”)Yes, while both are aliveA partition case under RPAPL Article 9
Tenants by the entirety (a married couple)Not while you’re marriedThe divorce case. After the divorce judgment, you own it as tenants in common
Still in a deceased owner’s nameGenerally not by the heirsSurrogate’s Court. The executor or administrator with Letters controls the sale

Unmarried co-owners. Under New York law, a deed to two or more people makes them tenants in common unless it expressly declares a joint tenancy (EPTL §6-2.2(a)). That covers most unmarried couples, friends, relatives and investors who bought together. Either kind of co-owner can bring a partition case (RPAPL §901).

Married couples. A deed to a married couple makes them tenants by the entirety unless it says otherwise (EPTL §6-2.2(b)). Partition isn’t the tool while you’re married: New York’s top court held that a court can’t order the sale of an entirety home unless a judgment of divorce, annulment or legal separation changes the marriage, and that after a divorce the former spouses become tenants in common (Kahn v Kahn, 43 NY2d 203, 1977). If you’re in a divorce now, read selling a house during a divorce in Buffalo and who gets the house in a New York divorce.

A house still in a parent’s name. Nobody can sell it until Surrogate’s Court issues Letters Testamentary or Letters of Administration. After that, the executor or administrator generally has the power to sell estate property on the terms they judge best, unless the will or the court order limits it or the will leaves the house to a specific person (EPTL §11-1.1). The heirs don’t each sign. When siblings disagree about that sale, our guide on what to do when siblings disagree about an inherited house walks through it.

How a partition case works

  1. The case is filed in the county where the house is. A case that affects title to real property is tried in that county (CPLR 507). Partition cases are usually filed in State Supreme Court, so for a Buffalo, Cheektowaga or Amherst house that means Erie County Supreme Court, and for a Niagara Falls or Lockport house, Niagara County Supreme Court.
  2. The court decides each owner’s share. The judgment sets out the right, share or interest of each party (RPAPL §915).
  3. The court tries to divide it, or orders a sale. If the property can be divided, the court names three disinterested commissioners to split it. If it can’t be divided without great prejudice to the owners, the court directs a sale at public auction (RPAPL §915). A single house on a city lot is usually hard to divide.
  4. Costs come off the top. The expenses of the sale and the parties’ court costs are paid from the proceeds, and unpaid property taxes, assessments and water charges that are liens on the house are paid from the sale too (RPAPL §981). The court can also adjust for rents and profits between the owners (RPAPL §945).
  5. The rest is split by ownership share.

How long it takes depends on the court, whether anyone contests ownership or the shares, and whether the house is heirs property. A partition case can take many months.

Inherited houses: the Heirs Property Act

New York added the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act as RPAPL §993 (Laws of 2019, chapter 596, signed and effective December 6, 2019). It applies to partition cases filed on or after that date. A 2024 law added two more protections, in effect since July 19, 2024: a share buyer can’t start a partition case, and the family gets the first chance to match an outside offer for a share (Laws of 2024, chapter 56, Part O).

What counts as heirs property. A house owned as tenants in common, used for residential or agricultural purposes, with no written agreement among all the owners about partition, where at least one owner got title from a relative, and one of these is true: relatives hold 20% or more of the interests, someone who got title from a relative holds 20% or more, 20% or more of the owners are relatives, or an owner who got title from a relative lives there. The court decides whether the house qualifies.

What changes when it applies:

  • A settlement conference first. The court holds a mandatory conference, both sides must negotiate in good faith, and if the owner who filed doesn’t, the case is dismissed.
  • An appraisal. Unless the owners agree on a value, the court orders an appraisal by a disinterested New York-licensed appraiser.
  • A buyout right. Owners who didn’t ask for a sale can elect to buy out the ones who did, at the court-set value times their share, within 45 days after notice of the value.
  • Dividing the land comes first. If no buyout happens, the court orders partition in kind unless that would cause great manifest prejudice to the owners as a group.
  • Usually an open-market sale, not an auction. If the court orders a sale, a licensed broker generally offers the house in a commercially reasonable way at a price no lower than the value the court set. The court can order sealed bids or an auction instead only if it finds that would serve the owners better as a group.
  • Share buyers can’t start one. Since July 19, 2024, someone who bought or otherwise got a share other than by inheritance can’t start a partition case over heirs property. The narrow exception is a share inherited directly from someone who owned it before the house became heirs property, or from an owner who was an heir (RPAPL §993(12)).
  • The family gets the first chance at an outside offer. Since the same date, if an owner gets a genuine offer for their share from someone who isn’t already an owner and plans to accept it or counter, the owners who inherited their shares, and owners related to them, can buy that share at the same price and terms. An owner who lives in the house gets first priority. The outside buyer and the selling owner both have to make a diligent effort to find and notify every other owner, and the others get 180 days from notice to match the offer. If they weren’t notified and the sale goes through anyway, they can buy the share from the outside buyer for what that buyer paid plus 2% a year, within 180 days of learning of the sale (RPAPL §993(13)).

Many houses passed down within a family can fit the definition. For how this plays out between siblings, see our guide on siblings who disagree about an inherited house, and our guide to selling an inherited house in Buffalo.

What a forced sale costs everyone

  • Time. It’s a lawsuit, with filings, notices, a judgment and then a sale.
  • Money. The sale expenses and the parties’ court costs come out of the proceeds before anyone is paid.
  • Control. Outside heirs property, the default is a public auction, and the owners don’t pick the buyer, the price or the date.
  • The house keeps costing money. Taxes, insurance, utilities and any mortgage keep coming due while the case runs, and an empty house can pick up damage and code problems.
  • Relationships. Suing a former partner, a sibling or a friend tends to end the relationship.

The cheaper paths

Here’s the honest version: the cheapest way out is often for all the owners to agree to sell together. Before anyone files, these are worth a real try:

  • One owner buys the other out. Agree on a value, often with an appraisal, and the buying owner pays the other for their share.
  • Everyone sells together. List it with an agent, or sell it as-is for cash. Every owner signs, and the proceeds are split the way you agree.
  • Sell only your share. A co-owner can legally sell their own undivided interest, but the buyer becomes a co-owner with the people you couldn’t agree with. It rarely ends the dispute. With heirs property, the other family owners get 180 days after notice to match any outside offer for your share, and the buyer can’t start a partition case.

If the house is updated and everyone can wait, listing it will likely bring the highest price. A cash sale fits when the house needs work, someone is carrying costs they can’t keep up, or every extra decision turns into another argument.

Where we fit

We buy the whole house when every owner on the deed signs, or when the executor or administrator signs for an estate after Letters issue. If one owner won’t sign, we can’t buy the whole house, and we’ll tell you that up front.

We also buy one owner’s share of a house (a partial interest). Here are the honest limits. We would become a co-owner with the other owners, they keep every right they had, and we can’t promise what happens after that. If the house is heirs property, the other family owners can match our offer for your share within 180 days of being notified, and as a share buyer we couldn’t start a partition case (RPAPL §993(12) and (13)). If the house is in foreclosure, an owner who sells to us, even just a share, generally has 14 business days to cancel the contract (Real Property Law §265-a).

A cash offer is our main option, made within 24 hours, usually by phone. We buy as-is in Buffalo, Cheektowaga, Amherst, Tonawanda and Niagara Falls. Take what you want and leave the rest. We cover all closing costs, and there are no open houses. If a co-owner lives out of town, see selling a Buffalo house from out of state.

We look at a lot of houses, and we can’t buy every one. If a cash sale isn’t a good fit for yours, we’ll say so first. We may also have other solutions, so tell us your situation.

Close in as little as 5 days when the title is clear and ready. Most closings take 14–30 days.

Want to talk it through first? Contact us or call (716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274.

Get your cash offer

Cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.

Name

Questions co-owners ask

Do I need the other owner’s permission to file for partition?

No. A joint tenant or tenant in common can bring a partition case without the other owner’s consent (RPAPL §901). The other owners are named in the case and get to respond.

We’re divorced but both still on the deed. Can my ex force a sale?

Yes. Once the divorce judgment is entered, a tenancy by the entirety becomes a tenancy in common, and a tenant in common can bring a partition case. Check your divorce judgment or settlement first, because it may already say what happens to the house. If it says to sell and your ex won’t sign the deed, see how to enforce the judgment.

My partner and I aren’t married and split up. Can either of us force a sale?

Generally, yes. Unless your deed says otherwise, unmarried co-owners are tenants in common, and either one can file for partition. If you can agree on a buyout or a sale, you skip the court costs.

I live in the house and pay the bills. Can a co-owner still force a sale?

Yes. Living there doesn’t block a partition case. The court can adjust rents and profits between the owners when it divides the money (RPAPL §945), so keep records of what you’ve paid.

Where would the case be heard in Erie or Niagara County?

In the county where the house is (CPLR 507). Partition cases are usually filed in State Supreme Court: Erie County Supreme Court in Buffalo, or Niagara County Supreme Court for Niagara County houses.

Sources

  • NY Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law §901, partition: by whom maintainable (nysenate.gov, revision 2014-09-22; checked October 2026)
  • RPAPL §915, interlocutory judgment (commissioners; sale at public auction when partition would cause great prejudice) (nysenate.gov, revision 2014-09-22)
  • RPAPL §945, judgment adjusting rents and profits, and §981, costs and expenses (nysenate.gov, revision 2014-09-22)
  • RPAPL §993, Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act (nysenate.gov, revision 2024-07-26; checked October 2026)
  • Senate Bill S4865A of 2019, signed December 6, 2019 as chapter 596, “This act shall take effect immediately” (nysenate.gov)
  • Laws of 2024, chapter 56 (Senate Bill S8306-C / Assembly Bill A8806-C), Part O §§10 and 11, adding RPAPL §993(12) and (13); signed April 20, 2024; Part O took effect on the ninetieth day after it became law, July 19, 2024 (nysenate.gov and nyassembly.gov bill text; checked October 2026)
  • Real Property Law §265-a, Home Equity Theft Prevention Act, 14-business-day right to cancel in subdivision 5(a) (nysenate.gov, revision 2023-12-15; checked October 2026)
  • Estates, Powers and Trusts Law §6-2.2, tenancy in common, joint tenancy and tenancy by the entirety (nysenate.gov, revision 2019-11-01)
  • EPTL §11-1.1, fiduciaries’ powers, including the power to sell (nysenate.gov, revision 2014-09-22)
  • CPLR 507, place of trial for real property actions (nysenate.gov, revision 2014-09-22)
  • Kahn v Kahn, 43 NY2d 203 (1977), New York Court of Appeals

General information about New York law as of October 2026, not legal advice. Rust Belt Cash Offer is a home buyer, not a law firm. Rust Belt Cash Offer · 50 Fountain Plaza, Suite 1400, Buffalo, NY 14202 · (716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274

Scroll to Top
Rust Belt Cash Offer
Rust Belt Cash Offer
Hey! Got a Buffalo property you're thinking about? Happy to help.
★★★★★
Google 5.0 reviews
Since 2020
Buying WNY houses
350+
Homes bought
BBB A+
Accredited since 6/2/2021
(716) 800-2274 Tap to call
Rust Belt Cash Offer logo

Rust Belt Cash Offer

(716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274

Phone answered 24/7 · Hablamos español

Rust Belt Cash Offer · 50 Fountain Plaza, Suite 1400, Buffalo, NY 14202 · (716) 800-2274 · https://www.rbcashoffer.com/ · info@rbcashoffer.com

Printed from: https://www.rbcashoffer.com/blog/force-sale-of-house-new-york-partition/
Page last updated: October 31, 2026

General information, not legal advice. Rust Belt Cash Offer is a home buyer, not a law firm.