How do I get the fire report for my Buffalo house?
Get a cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.
Ask the City of Buffalo for it in writing under New York’s Freedom of Information Law (FOIL). The simplest way is the City’s online FOIL portal, buffalony.nextrequest.com, which takes requests for records kept by the City. (Buffalo Police records go through a separate police portal.) Give the property address, the date of the fire and the records you want: the fire incident report and any fire investigation report.
The clock is set by law. The City has 5 business days to grant the request, deny it, or acknowledge it in writing with an approximate date. Paper copies can cost no more than 25 cents a page, and you don’t have to say why you want them.
Facts checked as of October 19, 2026. General information, not legal advice. This page covers the City of Buffalo, with notes for towns in Erie and Niagara County.
- BBB A+ rated, Accredited since 6/2/2021
- 350+ houses bought and sold
What “the fire report” usually means
People say “the fire report” for two different records, and it helps to ask for both by name:
- The incident report. The basic record of the fire: the address, the date and time, the companies that responded and what they found.
- The fire investigation report. The City’s code gives the Bureau of Fire Prevention, in the Fire Department, the job of investigating the cause, origin and circumstances of certain fires (Buffalo Code, chapter 103, article III). Not every fire gets a full investigation, so this record may not exist for yours.
The same part of the City’s code also has a section on Fire Department records. Either way, ask for both records by name and let the City tell you what it has.
How to request it in Buffalo
- Use the City’s FOIL portal. Go to buffalony.nextrequest.com and make a new request. The portal says it handles requests for records maintained by the City of Buffalo and suggests checking the City’s open data site, data.buffalony.gov, first.
- Or put it in writing another way. FOIL lets you write to the agency’s records access officer by mail, by hand or by email. The law says an agency that has the means to take requests by email has to accept them (Public Officers Law §89(3)(b)), and the state’s Committee on Open Government has said an agency can’t make its own online form the only way to ask.
- Describe the record clearly. FOIL covers a “record reasonably described.” Give the street address, the date of the fire, the approximate time if you know it, and the incident number if a firefighter or your insurer gave you one. Say you want the Buffalo Fire Department incident report and any fire investigation report.
- Ask for electronic copies. A PDF by email is usually the fastest way to get it and can cost less than paper.
You don’t have to explain why you want the report. The Committee on Open Government’s FOIL guidance says a requester can’t be required to give a reason or say how the records will be used.
How long it takes and what it costs
- 5 business days to respond. Within 5 business days after it gets your written request, the City has to make the record available, deny the request in writing, or send a written acknowledgment with an approximate date (Public Officers Law §89(3)(a)).
- The date has to be reasonable. If the City can’t grant the request within 20 business days after that acknowledgment, it has to tell you why in writing and give you a date (§89(3)(a)).
- Copy fees are capped. For paper copies up to 9 by 14 inches, the fee can’t be more than 25 cents a page (Public Officers Law §87(1)(b)(iii)).
What can be blacked out or held back
FOIL starts from the idea that government records are open, with limited exceptions. Two of them come up with fire records:
- Personal privacy. An agency can withhold parts of a record that would be an “unwarranted invasion of personal privacy” if released (§87(2)(b)). Expect details about other people, like injured occupants, to be blacked out.
- An open investigation. Records compiled for law enforcement can be withheld to the extent that releasing them would interfere with an investigation or court case (§87(2)(e)). If the fire is being investigated as a possible arson, part of the file may be held back for a while.
Even then, the City generally can’t refuse the whole thing. In a 2009 advisory opinion, the Committee on Open Government said the fact that a fire occurred and was recorded is information the public can get, while records showing the course of an arson investigation might be withheld “perhaps for a time” (FOIL advisory opinion 17882).
If the City says no
You can appeal in writing within 30 days of the denial, to the person the City names to decide FOIL appeals. The City then has 10 business days to give you the records or explain in writing why it is denying them (Public Officers Law §89(4)(a)). The Committee on Open Government’s guidance says that if an agency misses its deadline, you can treat that as a denial and appeal.
Outside the City of Buffalo
Most towns in Erie and Niagara County are covered by a volunteer fire company or a fire district, not a city department. FOIL still applies. The Committee on Open Government says New York’s highest court held in 1980 that volunteer fire companies are generally “agencies” under FOIL (Westchester Rockland Newspapers v. Kimball, 50 N.Y.2d 575), and it has applied FOIL to an incorporated fire company and to a fire district (advisory opinions 19197 and 19868).
Send the request to the fire company or district that answered the call. If you don’t know which one that was, ask your town clerk. If the house is in another city, like Lackawanna or Niagara Falls, send the request to that city.
How the report helps with insurance and a sale
The insurance claim. Your insurer or adjuster may ask for the report or the incident number. Our guide to selling a fire-damaged house in Buffalo covers the claim itself: how long the insurer has to respond under state rules, why the check has your lender’s name on it, and how to keep coverage on an empty house.
If you are thinking about selling after the fire, here is how we sell a fire-damaged house in Buffalo.
The sale. In most sales of a one- to four-family home, you owe the buyer a Property Condition Disclosure Statement before the buyer signs a binding contract. Question 29 asks: “Is there any fire or smoke damage to the structure or structures?” and asks you to explain if the answer is yes (Real Property Law §462). The form doesn’t ask you to attach the fire report, but having it makes your answer clear and complete. Some sales are exempt from the form, such as a sale by an executor or administrator settling an estate (Real Property Law §463).
Buyers, contractors and lenders may all ask for the report. If the City boarded the house up or ordered it secured after the fire, read what a Buffalo condemnation notice means, and if it sent a bill for that work, see selling a house the City boarded up or billed for demolition.
Where we fit
We buy fire-damaged houses as-is in Buffalo, including Black Rock and Lovejoy, and across Erie County in towns like Cheektowaga and Tonawanda. We can buy with the fire insurance claim assigned to us, and your attorney can confirm how the claim is handled in the sale. You can take what you want and leave the rest, we cover all closing costs, and there are no open houses. A cash offer is our main option, made within 24 hours, usually by phone.
We can’t buy every house. If the insurance money covers a full repair and you have the time to manage it, fixing the house and listing it may bring you more, and we’ll say so. We may also have other solutions, so tell us your situation.
Close in as little as 5 days when the title is clear and ready. Title problems? If we’re buying the deed without an attorney or title insurance, we can close in as little as 48–72 hours. Most closings take 14–30 days.
Want to talk it through first? Contact us or call (716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274. Or see how we buy houses in Buffalo.
Get your cash offer
Cash offer within 24 hours, usually by phone.
Questions sellers ask
Do I have to fill out the City’s own FOIL form?
No. A written request that reasonably describes the record is enough. The Committee on Open Government has said an agency can’t insist on its own online form, and an agency that can take email has to accept requests that way. The portal is still the easiest route in Buffalo because it tracks your request.
The fire was years ago. Can I still get the report?
If the City still has the record, yes. FOIL covers records an agency keeps, no matter how old the event is. The Committee on Open Government has said this even for records of a fire from 1967, before FOIL existed (advisory opinion 19701).
Will the report tell me what caused the fire?
Maybe. The incident report records what the firefighters found. The cause is in the investigation report, if there was one. If the investigation is still open, that part may be held back for a while.
Can anyone get the fire report for my house?
Generally, yes. FOIL lets any person request records, and the basic facts of a fire are public. Personal details about the people involved can be blacked out.
Do I need the fire report before I sell?
Not to start. The disclosure form asks whether there is fire or smoke damage, not for a copy of the report. A buyer, a lender or your insurer may still ask for it, so request it early.
Sources
- New York Public Officers Law §89(3)(a), (3)(b) and (4)(a) (5 business days, 20 business days, email requests, 30-day appeal, 10 business days to decide) (nysenate.gov, revision 2022-08-19; read October 19, 2026)
- New York Public Officers Law §87(1)(b)(iii), (2)(b) and (2)(e) (25-cent copy fee cap, personal privacy, law enforcement records) (nysenate.gov, revision 2026-09-18; read October 19, 2026)
- NYS Committee on Open Government, Freedom of Information Law page and FAQ (how to make a request, no reason required, missed deadlines, appeals) (opengovernment.ny.gov; read October 19, 2026)
- NYS Committee on Open Government, FOIL advisory opinions 17882 (November 5, 2009, fire incident records and arson investigations), 19701 (January 4, 2019, records of a 1967 fire), 19868 (September 23, 2024, a fire district must accept written and email requests, not only its online form) and 19197 (October 30, 2014, incorporated volunteer fire companies are subject to FOIL)
- Westchester Rockland Newspapers v. Kimball, 50 N.Y.2d 575 (1980), as described by the Committee on Open Government in advisory opinion 19197 (the decision itself was not read)
- City of Buffalo FOIL portal (buffalony.nextrequest.com; Buffalo Police Department requests through its own portal) (read October 19, 2026)
- Buffalo City Code, chapter 103, article III, Fire Prevention, including its fire investigation and Fire Department records sections (eCode360, version dated 2025-09-02; seen through search excerpts only, October 19, 2026)
- New York Real Property Law §462, Property Condition Disclosure Statement, Question 29 (nysenate.gov, revision 2025-07-04) and §463 exemptions
General information about getting fire records in the City of Buffalo and Western New York as of October 19, 2026, not legal advice. Rust Belt Cash Offer is a home buyer, not a law firm. Rust Belt Cash Offer · 50 Fountain Plaza, Suite 1400, Buffalo, NY 14202 · (716) 800-CASH · (716) 800-2274